HIPAA Violation Examples: What to Avoid & How to Stay Compliant

‍

What do you think is the ballpark figure for damage from one mistake? HCA Healthcare faced a data breach that resulted in the exposure of 11 million patient records in 2023. The repercussions? Lawsuits, regulatory investigation, and reputational damage. This wasn't merely a security failure; it was a HIPAA compliance violation. 

You are misguided if you think HIPAA violations are just financial penalties. They disrupt operations, damage credibility, and lead to legal action.  It is stated that one single violation of HIPAA can cost up to $1.9 million, and failure to comply with it can impact even established organisations. 

If you want to know more about HIPAA Violations, keep on reading. In this guide, you will learn about the most frequent violations, workplace violations to avoid, and tips on how to stay compliant. 

‍

TL;DR 

• HIPAA violations can cost organizations up to $1.9 million per incident and lead to legal action, operational disruptions, and reputation damage.
• Common violations include unauthorized access to patient records, failure to secure electronic PHI, improper disposal of records, inadequate staff training, and not encrypting devices.
• Workplace violations often occur through casual conversations in public areas, unsecured workstations, use of personal devices, sending PHI to wrong recipients, and improper record disposal.
• The severity of consequences depends on whether violations are unintentional or willful, with the latter potentially resulting in termination, criminal charges, and jail time.
• Best practices for compliance include implementing strong access controls, encrypting all data, providing regular staff training, and conducting system monitoring and audits.

‍

1. What is HIPAA, and Why is Compliance Critical? 

HIPAA (Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act) is a U.S. federal law enacted in 1996 to protect sensitive patient health information from being disclosed without consent. It establishes national standards for safeguarding medical records and other personal health data.

A HIPAA violation occurs when an organization does not follow the standards and regulations set by HIPAA. This means that Protected Health Information (PHI) has been put at risk, either by being exposed, accessed by someone who shouldn't have access, or improperly handled, whether on purpose or by accident. 

When we talk about compliance, it is not just about following rules; it concerns protecting patient trust, ensuring smooth operations, and maintaining financial stability. The infamous example of Banner Health's data breach in 2022 cost them a fine of $1.25 million after a data breach leaked almost 3.5 million patients’ records. This indicates how noncompliance can result in hefty fines. 

‍

‍

HIPAA compliance is a core responsibility of organizations that handle patient data. Be it hospitals or SaaS healthcare vendors, everyone needs compliance. Everyone in the industry must ensure that their systems, processes, and employees align with HIPAA's requirements.

Now, you must be wondering what constitutes a HIPAA Violation. Well, below are 8 common Violations in Healthcare that, when affected, can result in noncompliance to HIPPA. 

‍

2. What are considered HIPAA Violations?

HIPAA Violations don't only occur due to intentional breaches, they can turn into serious compliance violations even with the smallest gap in security. The slightest overlook or misstep, such as sending PHI (Protected Health Information) to the wrong person or not encrypting a device, can put sensitive patient information at risk. 

The reality is that most healthcare organizations struggle with compliance because their policies are out of date, their staff members are not adequately trained, or they rely too heavily on external vendors. Unless these problems are addressed, they can result in costly mistakes. 

Here is a list of 8 HIPAA Violations with real-life case studies to address the issue of noncompliance and its consequences. 

A. Unauthorized Access to Patient Information

The strength of data security hinges on its weakest point, often an internal one. Employees looking at patient records without a valid reason cause one of the most frequent HIPAA breaches. 

This unauthorized access, whether driven by curiosity, personal interest, or even bad intentions, violates patient privacy and puts healthcare organizations at risk of harsh penalties. Even staff members with good intentions who check on a friend or relative's health status without permission can trigger a compliance issue.

a. Real-Life Case: UCLA Health System

In 2011, UCLA Health System had to pay $865,000 to settle a HIPAA violation. This happened because staff members kept looking at the electronic health records of famous patients without permission. The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) looked into the issue and found that the hospital didn't have sufficient access controls in place. 

This allowed employees to look through patient information freely. Because of this, UCLA had to change its policies, increase employee training, and implement put stricter access restrictions. 

b. Takeaway

Healthcare organizations must put in place strict access controls to make sure authorized personnel can see PHI. To stop unauthorized viewing of patient data, they can use role-based access limits, audit logs, and real-time tracking. It's also crucial to train staff on privacy rules so they understand the consequence of improper access.

On top of that, organizations should enforce penalties for unauthorized access. Employees need to know that viewing patient records without a legitimate reason isn't just a small error, it's a serious compliance issue that can lead to termination, fines, and legal actions.

B. Failure to Secure Electronic Protected Health Information (ePHI)

In our current healthcare world, where digital comes first, keeping electronic-protected health information (ePHI) safe has become crucial. Still, many organizations fail to implement enough security, which leaves sensitive patient information vulnerable to cyber risks. 

Whether it's weak passwords, data without encryption, or improper storage of ePHI, even small security gaps can cause colossal data leaks.

HIPAA's Security Rule mandates that organizations must apply administrative, physical, and tech safeguards to protect ePHI. However, many healthcare providers still use outdated systems or don't enforce security protocols, which makes them prime targets for cybercriminals.

a. Real-Life Case: Premera Blue Cross 

In 2015, Premera Blue Cross experienced a huge data leak that exposed 10.4 million people's personal health information. Hackers broke into Premera's network because of weak security controls, and the breach went undetected for almost nine months. 

Investigations showed that the company failed to comply with timely security risk assessments and failed to protect ePHI. As a result, Premera had to pay a $6.85 million fine in a HIPAA settlement and change its cybersecurity rules. 

b. Takeaway 

Healthcare companies need to be more proactive about ePHI security. This means encrypting all patient data, using multi-factor authentication, and often updating security protocols to fight new cyber threats. Using AI-powered monitoring systems can help spot suspicious activity before a breach happens.

Also, it's essential to train employees on cybersecurity. Human error is still one of the biggest weak spots in keeping data safe, so it's crucial to make sure staff know how to handle ePHI.

C. Inadequate Disposal of PHI

Inadequate disposal of patient data can be as harmful as not protecting it. Paper records discarded in the trash or unencrypted hard drives dumped without erasure, for instance, can cause serious HIPAA infractions. 

Improperly disposed documents and digital files are a prime target of criminals looking to steal sensitive information, exposing patients and healthcare organizations to danger. HIPAA mandates covered entities to employ secure disposal practices like shredding, degaussing, or permanently erasing electronic records.  

a. Real-Life Case: Affinity Health Plan 

Affinity Health Plan, an insurer in New York, learned the hard way when it did not erase sensitive information from photocopier hard drives before returning leased equipment. It was found by investigators that the copiers had confidential medical information of more than 344,000 people. 

Affinity paid a $1.2 million HIPAA settlement and revamped its disposal practices as a consequence. 

b. Takeaway

The proper disposal of PHI needs to be of utmost importance for healthcare organizations. Paper records should be shredded, incinerated, or pulped, whereas electronic data has to be wiped out permanently using industry standard methods. Deleting files alone is insufficient; organizations must hire certified data destruction services for permanent elimination.

D. Lack of Adequate HIPAA Compliance Training for Staff

Most HIPAA violations happen due to employee mistakes rather than malicious actions. When staff members aren't properly trained, they may not understand the risks associated with mishandling protected health information (PHI). 

This can lead to unintentional breaches of HIPAA regulations, such as discussing PHI in public or mistakenly sending patient records to the wrong person. For proper compliance with the HIPAA Privacy and Security Rules, employees who work with PHI need to receive ongoing training from their organizations. 

a. Real-Life Case:  Memorial Healthcare System

At Memorial Healthcare System (MHS), employees improperly accessed protected health information, leading to a significant violation of HIPAA regulations. Over 115,000 patient records were affected due to the organization's insufficient training on monitoring practices and access restrictions. 

After an investigation, MHS had to enhance its employee training program and agreed to a settlement of $5.5 million.

b. Takeaway

Employee training should be a continuous process instead of just a one-time event. Healthcare organizations need to regularly refresh their training materials to reflect the latest HIPAA regulations, cybersecurity threats, and best practices for handling PHI. 

Interactive training sessions that include phishing simulations and real-life scenarios can help employees recognize potential risks. Additionally, organizations should implement role-based permissions and strict access controls to minimize human error. 

E.  Failure to Provide Patients with Access to Their Records

Patients have the right, upon request, to receive their medical records within the framework of HIPAA. Some healthcare providers, for some reason, do not meet such requests because of poorly organized office work, outdated record systems, or ignorance of legal compliance requirements. 

Often, patients need access to their medical histories for ongoing treatment, seeking second opinions, or even for insurance. Not only does unnecessary denial or delay of access impact patient care negatively, it can also have regulatory repercussions for the providers.

a. Real-Life Case: Bayfront Health St. Petersburg

A Florida-based Bayfront Health Hospital had to settle for $85,000 on HIPAA violations after failing to give a mother timely access to her child’s medical records. The hospital took over nine months to fulfill the request, which completely disregarded HIPAA’s 30-day window.

Due to these actions, the Office for Civil Rights (OCR) had to impose penalties along with corrective actions. 

b. Takeaway

Healthcare organizations must adopt applicable procedures for the management of record access requests. This involves creating procedures with strict timelines, transforming records to electronic formats for easier access, and staff training on the Right of Access under HIPAA.

Not adhering to the guidelines can incur fines and damage patient trust. The implementation of electronic health record (EHR) systems can make access easier and prevent compliance concerns. 

F. Data Breaches Due to Third-Party Vendors

Numerous healthcare organizations depend on third-party vendors for data storage, billing, and IT services. However, without adequate security protocols, these entities may become the weakest link in HIPAA compliance. A vendor breach puts patient information at risk, making healthcare providers liable for non-compliance.  

Under HIPAA’s Business Associate Agreement (BAA), healthcare entities are required to ensure that all of their vendors comply with the same security and privacy standards. Organizations without a robust BAA and regular audits face increased third-party cybersecurity risks, which leads to costly breaches.  

a. Real-Life Case: AMCA Data Breach

The American Medical Collection Agency (AMCA), a third-party vendor for medical billing, lost twenty-five million patient records due to a cyberattack in 2019. Renowned healthcare providers such as Quest Diagnostics and LabCorp experienced losses. AMCA ultimately declared bankruptcy after facing recurring lawsuits.

b. Takeaway

Before any third party handles PHI, they should have a thorough vetting. As for healthcare organizations, they need to ensure that vendors comply with HIPAA regulations through security assessments.      

Regular audits and risk evaluations of third-party vendors can help detect weaknesses that might later become breaches. Furthermore, limiting vendors to only required data lowers overall exposure risk.

G. Not Encrypting Devices Used to Store PHI

One of the most common causes of HIPAA violations is lost or stolen devices with unencrypted PHI. It could be a lost laptop, an unencrypted USB stick, or a smartphone, if not encrypted, that could end up costing an organization millions due to breach and penalty fines.

Encryption provides lost devices with secure data. However, many providers still keep patient information in hard drives that are not encrypted and are, therefore, vulnerable to unauthorized access.

a. Real-Life Case: Feinstein Institute for Medical Research

Feinstein Institute for Medical Research suffered a $3.9 million fine due to HIPAA because an employee's laptop, which wasn’t encrypted and contained the PHI of 13,000 patients, was left in their car and subsequently stolen.

b. Takeaway

There should be strict practices regarding encryption for devices that store PHI. Healthcare entities must enforce encryption policies for laptops, mobile devices, and even USB drives. Moreover, the capability to remotely wipe devices should be utilized to delete information from salvaged or misplaced devices.

Safeguarding device usage practices and multi-factor authentication for employees can also improve the security posture. With encryption given priority, healthcare organizations will be able to mitigate data breaches and compliance issues.

H. Not Performing Regular Risk Evaluations 

A lot of healthcare organizations assume that their security measures are sufficient without proper and regulated assessments. Cybersecurity threats are evolving drastically, and the absence of risk assessment can leave vulnerability gaps. If no review is practiced, healthcare providers risk exposure of PHI to breaches, fines, and loss of reputation.

It is required by HIPAA that organizations perform regular risk assessments to find security loopholes. If these risk assessment is not conducted, a lot of security gaps in data protection exist that can be manipulated easily, resulting in cyberattacks. 

a. Real-Life Case: Anthem Inc. 

In 2015, hackers attacked Anthem Inc., exposing the PHI of 79 million people. Investigators discovered Anthem had not done a company-wide risk analysis, which let hackers take advantage of security flaws. This led to Anthem paying a record $16 million HIPAA fine. 

b. Takeaway

Companies should check for risks often, not just once. They should look at their security each year, update their plans to manage risks, and use tools that spot weak points.

Good records of risk checks can show that a company follows the rules if someone audits them. When healthcare providers fix security problems before they become issues, they can stop data breaches and stick to regulations.

‍

3. What is Considered a HIPAA Violation in the Workplace?

After reading the previous section, you must now be aware of the different examples of HIPAA violations and how they can result in hefty fines and reputational damage if overlooked. 

In this part, you will learn about HIPAA violations that take place in a workplace, often unintentionally. The most simple mistake, like leaving your computer unlocked, can result in a costly compliance breach. 

A. Conversations in Public Areas

Healthcare workers often talk about patient care, but these talks in hallways, elevators, or cafeterias can break HIPAA rules. Even without names, someone overhearing private information can count as sharing it without permission.

Healthcare professionals must be mindful of their surroundings and avoid discussing sensitive patient information in areas where unauthorized individuals might overhear. Organizations should establish strict privacy policies to reinforce this practice.

B. Unsecured Workstations and Devices

Not locking computers or using personal gadgets without proper coding is a typical HIPAA no-no. It takes just moments for someone who shouldn't to get their hands on sensitive patient info.

Healthcare facilities should enforce automatic screen locks after a period of inactivity and require employees to manually lock their devices before leaving their desks. This simple practice helps prevent unauthorized access and potential data breaches. 

C. Usage of Personal Devices for Work

When employees use their phones, computers, or tablets to do work stuff, they might break HIPAA rules without meaning to if those devices don't have proper security and encryption. Personal gadgets often don't have the security measures they need, which makes them more likely to get hacked. 

Companies need a well-defined BYOD policy to make sure personal devices that access PHI meet strict security rules. These rules should include data encryption, the ability to wipe data, and two-step login processes. 

D. Sending PHI to Wrong Recipients 

Misdirected emails, faxes, or messages often lead to HIPAA violations. A small error in typing an email address can result in PHI being sent to an unauthorized recipient. This leads to a data breach and potential penalties. 

Implementing secure messaging platforms and mandating staff to verify recipient details before sending any sensitive information can help in preventing unintentional breaches. Access controls and encryptions can also reduce the possibility of such diaclousres. 

E. Improper Patient Record Disposal 

A HIPAA breach may result from the improper disposal of paper documents, hard drives, or electronic devices. PHI can be readily recovered and misused by unauthorized people if it is thrown away in ordinary trash cans or stays on unwiped electronic devices.

Healthcare providers are required to adhere to secure disposal procedures, which include using certified data destruction services for electronic storage devices and shredding physical records. Regular compliance checks guarantee that the right disposal methods are always used.

Even if HIPAA violations are done through minor lapses in judgment, the consequences hold the same power as any other misconduct, including fines, legal actions, and reputational damages. 

‍

4. Will a HIPAA Violation get you fired?

When it comes to compliance with HIPAA, it is also about protecting your career. Whether the mistake was intentional or unintentional, both have the same level of consequences. Some employees may receive warnings, while others might get terminated and face serious legal actions. 

So, the real question is, if a HIPAA violation gets you fired? Honestly, the answer depends on the severity of the violation. The kind of HIPAA violation that is most likely to lead to firing is a malicious violation because it involves deliberate misconduct and a significant breach of trust. On the other hand, accidental and procedural violations, although still important, usually don't result in such severe penalties.

Here is a breakdown of how different violations impact job security.

A. Unintentional vs. Willful Violations 

Not all HIPAA violations are the same; if an employee makes an unintentional mistake, like sending PHI to the wrong person or discussing a case in an unsecured setting, they may receive a formal warning, additional training, or temporary suspension. 

However, if an employee willfully violates the law, such as by selling PHI, accessing patient records without authorization, or sharing information with malicious intent, they may face criminal charges and jail time. 

B. Criminal Charges and Penalties 

Serious HIPAA violations can result in criminal prosecution in addition to termination, which is a significant consequence. Employees risk fines, criminal prosecution, and possibly jail time if they steal, sell, or unlawfully share PHI.

Under HIPAA's penalty system, even less serious infractions, such as giving PHI to unauthorized parties, can result in fines of up to $50,000 each. In order to reduce liability and prevent additional financial penalties, employers who encounter such infractions may terminate personnel.

‍

5. Best Practices to Avoid HIPAA Violations

When we talk about compliance with HIPAA, it is not just about meeting legal requirements, it is an approach to building a culture of data accountability and security. 

Even the smallest of violations can lead to hefty fines, lawsuits, and years of reputational damage. This makes it crucial for organisations to implement strong preventive measures. 

A. Implement Strong Access Controls

Access to protected health information should be restricted to only those who need it to fulfill their job tasks. To stop unwanted access, organizations need to use role-based access restrictions, enforce multi-factor authentication (MFA), and periodically check permissions. 

Ignoring this can result in data breaches and insider threats, which are two of the most frequent reasons for HIPAA violations.

B. Secure and Encrypt Every Data

Data encryption guarantees that PHI cannot be read or misused, even in the event that unauthorized individuals manage to obtain it. End-to-end encryption should be used by organizations for cloud storage, emails, and electronic documents. 

To further guard against cyber attacks that target medical records, firewalls, antivirus programs, and secure networks need to be updated on a regular basis.

C. Provide Regular Training to Employees

Regular training is crucial for HIPAA compliance because employees are frequently the weakest link. Mandatory training sessions covering subjects including phishing attacks, password security, and appropriate PHI handling should be held by healthcare organizations at least twice a year. 

Additionally, staff may enforce compliance and identify vulnerabilities with the use of simulated cybersecurity exercises.

D. Monitor and Audit Systems

Tools for real-time monitoring should be utilized to keep tabs on login activity, identify questionable activity, and stop illegal access. Policies that enforce automatic logouts can also lessen the possibility that unwanted users will access unattended workstations. 

Organizations can detect weaknesses and rectify possible compliance gaps before they become infractions by conducting routine audits.

‍

6. How CloudEagle.ai Makes Compliance Easy for You

When you have so many SaaS applications handling Protected Health Information (PHI), staying compliant can certainly feel like a dreaded task.  Manual tracking, scattered security policies, and the risk of unauthorized access make HIPAA compliance a serious challenge.

‍

‍

That’s where CloudEagle.ai comes in. By automating compliance management, enforcing security protocols, and providing real-time monitoring, CloudEagle.ai ensures that your organization is always compliant with HIPAA. 

A. Centralized Compliance Management 

HIPAA violations can lead to massive fines and reputational damage, but CloudEagle.ai ensures continuous compliance by centralizing monitoring and security controls. It tracks user activity, app access, and PHI handling in one unified platform, reducing complexity and helping you detect and address potential compliance risks before they escalate.

With CloudEagle.ai, you can enforce HIPAA security policies without the need for multiple compliance tools. The platform ensures adherence to critical regulations, including HIPAA, SOC 2, and ISO 27001, by offering a centralized dashboard for access control, data security, and compliance tracking.

B. Automated Compliance Reporting

HIPAA audits require extensive documentation, but CloudEagle.ai simplifies the process with automated compliance reporting. The platform generates audit-ready reports with all necessary security and compliance data, ensuring you’re prepared for inspections without the burden of manual tracking.

Real-time audit logs provide full visibility into PHI access and user activity, making it easy to demonstrate compliance, monitor security risks, and quickly respond to potential violations before they become costly issues.

C. Continuous Monitoring & Risk Management

HIPAA compliance isn’t just about meeting regulatory requirements, it’s about actively protecting sensitive patient data. CloudEagle.ai provides real-time monitoring of user access and PHI transactions, ensuring that all security controls remain effective and detecting potential threats before they compromise your system.

‍

‍

With continuous monitoring, CloudEagle.ai identifies compliance gaps early and provides actionable insights to mitigate risks before they turn into major violations. This proactive approach helps healthcare organizations stay ahead of security threats and maintain a strong compliance posture.

D. Automated User Access Reviews  

HIPAA requires strict access controls to make sure that only those with permission can access PHI. CloudEagle.ai simplifies user access reviews by automatically tracking and verifying who can see sensitive information.

‍

‍

By implementing role-based access controls (RBAC) and conducting regular access audits, CloudEagle.ai guarantees that employees only access PHI when it's necessary. This approach helps to block unauthorized access and lowers the chances of data breaches.

E. Audit Trails 

Keeping a thorough audit trail is essential for HIPAA compliance. CloudEagle.ai records all system activities, user actions, and access events, providing complete transparency in how PHI is managed.

With customizable security policy enforcement, you can tailor compliance strategies to fit your organization’s unique requirements. Whether it’s limiting unauthorized access to PHI, enforcing data encryption, or setting up multi-factor authentication, CloudEagle.ai makes it easy to adhere to HIPAA’s stringent security standards.

‍

7. Final Thoughts 

After reading this entire blog, you now must be aware of how severe even the smallest of mistakes can cost your organization. A single breach can lead to fines in the millions, legal repercussions, and lasting damage to your reputation. 

However, achieving compliance doesn’t have to be a huge task. By adopting the practices discussed in this blog, like robust security protocols, providing thorough employee training, and implementing strict policies, organizations can proactively manage risks.

It can be a challenge to stay compliant with HIPAA, especially when you use several SaaS applications. With this many applications, securing PHI can be a tough job. This is where CloudEagle.ai can help you with streamlining compliance monitoring, identifying security vulnerabilities, and ensuring access controls. 

Ready to make HIPAA compliance easier and enhance the security of your SaaS environment? Book a demo with CloudEagle.ai today!

‍

Frequently asked questions

A. What is a HIPAA violation?
A HIPAA violation occurs when protected health information (PHI) is improperly accessed, disclosed, or handled, leading to privacy, security, or compliance breaches under HIPAA regulations.

B. What is an example of HIPAA?
An example is a hospital employee accessing patient records without authorization, violating HIPAA’s Privacy Rule by exposing sensitive medical information without patient consent.

C. Who comes under HIPAA?
HIPAA applies to healthcare providers, health plans, clearinghouses, and business associates that handle PHI, including hospitals, insurance companies, and third-party vendors.

D. How many types of HIPAA are there?

The three major HIPAA rules are The HIPAA Security Rule, The HIPAA Privacy Rule, and The HIPAA Breach Notification Rule.

‍